Oct 262014

Donald Trump bought the Menie Estate in 2006. By 2008, unprecedented planning permission was granted to create ‘the world’s greatest golf course’. The promise was a one billion pound spend, jobs for local people in the thousands, an increase in tourism in the thousands, and prosperity.

Menie Estate residents and those who stood up for them were vilified in the press; farmer Michael Forbes was said by Trump to live in a ‘pigsty’. What is life like at the estate for residents now? What are some of the issues and problems? Suzanne Kelly reports, in the first of a series.

A brief history of Trump
It was all meant to be better, so the proponents promised us: thousands of jobs, houses, tourists and money pouring into the north east. Never mind the loss of unique greenbelt and wildlife. To achieve this end, the existing environmental protection and normal planning procedure were swept aside.

Donald Trump was in the news whenever he opened his mouth, got on or off a plane, dined with Alex Salmond, or spoke out against wind farms. But when he vilified Michael Forbes, he really went to town. Forbes and his wife, and 90-year-old mother Molly live on a farm on the estate. They refused to move for Trump. Trump has had some damning things to say about the Forbes family, calling Michael the ‘village idiot’. About the Forbes Farm and home Trump said:-

“I just wish he would clean up his property, it is a pig sty. It’s terrible, his barn is all rusty and falling down. The hotel has the chance to be something really outstanding but it’s awfully hard when a window is overlooking a slum and you see rusting oil cans.” http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/177471/Protester-lives-in-a-pig-sty-says-furious-Trump

Trump International Golf Links Scotland must therefore be a rather special place. It recently won “The first and only Six Star Diamond Award” in Scotland, from the American Academy of Hospitality Sciences [what that? Ed]. The property must of course be cleaned up, there must be nothing slum-like about the place at all.

It may just be a coincidence that Donald Trump is on the American Academy of Hospitality Sciences Board, where he is listed as ‘Ambassador Extraordinaire’. Surely then, he and his companies know all about cleanliness, hygiene, environmental management and waste management.

At first glance at the golf course you see giant clocks, oversized lamps, parking, and a rather nondescript looking ‘temporary clubhouse’. Here is what you see today if you step off of the beaten track, photos supplied to Aberdeen Voice.

crestfallen waste at trump estate

Wooden frames featuring that Trump family crest are part of the debris off to the side of the parking lot, just adjacent to the Munro family property.

lamps at trump estate

Lights which shone into the Munro cottage from the parking lot were, amazingly, ordered to be removed by the council. On the day the council was to visit to make the decision about the lights, the lights were not switched on, as they normally would have been.

They are now dumped in the grass. Hopefully any chemicals such as mercury, or other toxic materials, will have long since been removed, even if the lamps remain.

plastic material at trump estate

Teed Off
Possibly most worrying are the yards and yards of plastic waste which could prove fatal to wildlife, either birds, or aquatic creatures, should it wind up in the nearby sea. The shore at Menie is unfortunately regularly peppered with plastic waste from marine activity.

A Lot Of Old Rubbish
These photos were taken in March 2013. They show mounds of rubbish on land on the Menie Estate. Whether the trash was burnt, buried, or disposed of legally remains unclear.  The issues with these piles of mixed waste include:

  • seemingly no attempt made at waste segregation for recycling;
  • plastic bottles with labels removed which contained unknown chemicals;
  • danger of chemicals leaching into the soil – and the sheer scale of the amount of rubbish involved.

Molly Forbes keeps chickens at her home on Michael’s farm; she calls her house ‘Paradise’.   Michael and Sheila live on a working farm; there are cats, chickens and geese (including a wild goose which is currently visiting).  As far as I could see, none of the taps at the farm place are gold plated; there are no red carpets and no hired showgirls to greet visitors. There are a good number of chickens, a few cats, and a warm atmosphere. Molly, Sheila and Michael might not get a ‘6 diamond’ special award. Perhaps they don’t want or need one.

The Forbes farm with friends

Wrapping Up
Perhaps rubbish is not really pollution if it has a Trump family crest carved on it. Perhaps the garbage will be properly segregated, recycled, and disposed of in the very near future. And just maybe someone who lives in a glass house who is so offended by the goings-on at a genuine working farm should clean up his own act before throwing any more stones.  Trump Golf Links has been asked to comment on the waste close to Leyton Farm Cottage.

In Part 2
Environmental monitoring evaporation, planning breaches and access issues.



  5 Responses to “The Trouble With Trump Part 1 – Trump Dump”

  1. You’re scraping the very bottom of the barrel with this one imo, utter biased nonsense. Why no pictures of Mr Forbes barns and surrounding areas?

  2. This is a scandal which, like the description of the predicted golf resort by the Scottish Government at the time they “called in” the application, is of “national significance”. That our very own Scottish Government played a leading role in foisting this carbuncle on our protected land and successfully circumvented established democratic procedure and planning law to fulfil the ambitions of their erstwhile favourite foreign billionaire is bad enough but that the promises of jobs and tourism turned out to be completely false adds insult to injury.

    A unique area of land, given the highest possible level of legal protection, was destroyed by our own government to satisfy the whim of someone, whom in my opinion, they thought would gain them political advantage whilst the human rights and lives of our own citizens became collateral damage in a cosy little accord between two of the most grotesquely vulgar individuals ever to walk a golf course. One a politician and the other merely rich.

    Perhaps the long – suffering residents might seek help from their MSP now that he has relinquished his old job and renewed his friendship with the Donald?

  3. Well said Bruce. There was a piece in the Sunday Sun headlined “Donald Dump” which was pretty apt when you look at the mess. Discarded trolleys were called “Stuck in the Rough: Wooden furniture cluttered around sheds were “The frame’s a bogey”: and ornamental lights had were ordered to be taken down by Aberdeenshire council because they were fixed on the Munro’s property were “Looking under par”. Now it is not often that I would praise what the Sun says, but on this occasion they were absolutely right. As they said “Tycoon’s course is in a right state.” Never a truer word spoken. As ever Mr. Trump’s spokesman declined to comment. If this mess had been left by erstwhile travellers there would have been an outcry in the local press. Have we heard a word? No. Could that be because Mrs.Bates works for Donald the Dump?

  4. First, to commenter Bill Stephens: You either didn’t see “You’ve Been Trumped” or you approve of his actions. The neighbors’ houses, barns etc., mostly Mike and Molly Forbes’s houses, were shown for all the world to see. The current president of my country, Trump, who was so ready to insult and the homeowners, has not bothered to check the back areas of his own “pristine” luxury golf course, and is uncaring about dumping their own waste products. Either you just woke up and know virtually nothing about what Trump has done to not only the residents but to the last natural ecologically pure coastal area of Scotland or you are of the same bullying mindset of this bIllionaire narcissistic land-grabber.

    • Hello, am pleased to see this slightly old piece still gets attention; am even more pleased that Tara has ‘nutshelled’ it so well. Thank you – Suzanne

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>